Sunday, November 21, 2004

Back Under the Covers

The Lawrence Journal-World's music critic had so much to say about A Perfect Circle's "Imagine" cover that he devoted an entire column to it last week. You might say we have differing opinions on the subject. So this is what it feels like to have a nemesis.

And as if "Imagine" isn't bad enough, even more iconic songs are being rehashed. Paul e-mailed me news regarding the latest travesty - he heard a butchered version of "In The Air Tonight" on the radio:
yeah, i'm not sure who it is. all i know is that the song was on a station similar to 93x in minneapolis. so, yes, it is a hard rock version of it, which makes it even worse. as much as i love hard rock and phil, they should never be paired. my guess is that it's some band like alien ant farm who butchered "smooth criminal" and then fell off the face of the planet. we can only hope this band follows suit.
More research than I'd care to admit revealed the source was a band named Nonpoint. The cover is among the tracks on their album "Recoil", and you can hear a clip at amazon. Before you listen, make sure you have a good internet connection, the latest version of Media Player, and plenty of gauze handy for when your ears begin to bleed.

And, as you ask your God how this could have happened, take a gander at the various groups that have covered "In the Air Tonight" before this latest instance. This is at least the seventh attempt to cover it! SEVEN!! That's like a new version every other year since its original release!

So I guess if New Year's 2006 rolls around and you think to yourself, "I could really use a jazzed up version of 'In the Air Tonight' right about now," you may be in luck.

2 comments:

Floyd said...

I disagree about A Perfect Circle's version of "Imagine". While I'm not about to buy the album, or even a PC fan, I think it is a decent cover. I enjoy the creepy, much more hopeless tone their version compared to Lennon's, in which Lennon's utopian ideal is replaced with a less enthusiastic vision of nothingness. As far as the inappropriateness of covering a song with deep political or philosophical meaning, if I'm not mistaken, APC's new album is an anti-war album, and they felt that covering the best anti-war song ever written was appropriate. And I think they did a decent enough job. So fuck you.

dn said...

Nuh-uh. It sucks.